Suzanne Collins (Photography) http://www.scollinsphoto.com Eveybody wants to sign

Just some of the comments made on our petition
Your comments !

Shopping Basket
So what the cost


Read about
PEOPLE POWER

Why should you have to travel to
Balbriggan,
Trim,
Ardee
,
Dundalk
to have a
VARIETY of shopping.

Taking on the grocer kings
It’s time to stop talking about RIP OFF IRELAND
Do your Lidl bit and sign our petition. Sign our petition


James O'Neill is a father of one child and is living on the lone-parent allowance of €168.10 a week. He is seeking signatures for a campaign in support of a planning application by German discounter Lidl, which wants to open a discount store in Drogheda, Co Louth.

Lidl's plans are in jeopardy after the grocers' lobby group RGDATA earlier this year appealed against planning permission for the discount store at the M1 retail park.

The appeal has enraged some Drogheda locals who see RGDATA as propping up the local grocers' interests at the expense of the consumer.

“[Tánaiste] Mary Harney went on national TV and told me to shop around. She is dead right.

“But I can't - because somebody is stopping me from it,” O'Neill said.

Even so, O'Neill often makes the journey to shop in discount stores in other towns and counties.

“We travel toLidl in a bunch to Balbriggan [Co Dublin]. We share the petrol with a bunch of lone parents. There is no way I can shop in my local shops, because I can't afford to,” he said.

O'Neill said a recent shop at Lidl cost just €85, compared with €138 at SuperValu, for what he said was a broadly similar basket.

RGDATA represents the interests of SuperValu franchisees, other symbol groups and the distributors who supply them.

He has no time for the view that Lidl will put the small grocer out of business. He reckons that, while the local Centra, Spar and Londis stores are owned by independent franchisees, they are effectively under the control of the big distributors who supply them with their stock.

“What small guy? Show me where the small guy is,” he said.

O'Neill is also worried about the impact that rising fuel prices will have on his disposable income. He says his fuel allowance of €12.90 a week, for which he will be eligible later in the autumn, will not be adequate to meet his needs.

The St Vincent de Paul charity recently supplied him with a big duvet to keep him warm in the winter months, when his heating bills are likely to soar due to mounting energy costs.

But, while he is one of the charity's customers, O'Neill said he rejected the arguments made by St Vincent de Paul in support of retaining the Groceries Order.

The Groceries Order bans below-cost selling, and prevents retailers from passing on discounts to consumers.

The government-appointed Consumer Strategy Group earlier this year estimated those discounts could be worth as much as 18 per cent. That would represent a very big saving to a person living on €168.10 a week.

The Competition Authority has calculated that abolishing the order would save the average household €481 a year.

It said that the householders on the lowest income would save €206 a year, representing 3.04 per cent of their weekly budget, while high-income households could save up to €706 or 0.78 per cent of their weekly income.

St Vincent de Paul, Crosscare and the Combat Poverty Agency are all opposed to abolishing the Groceries Order.

But if O'Neill is representative of their clientele, it would appear the agencies may be out of touch with at least some of their own constituents.

“The people working in St Vincent de Paul are getting a wage.

“How are they protecting my interests if they are denying me freedom of choice?” O'Neill asked.

One important issue with which the charities are concerned is food poverty, particularly the non-availability of nutritious foods, such as fresh fruit and vegetables, in poorer areas.

But O'Neill, who has recently shed five stone, said one of his problems was that he couldn't afford fresh fruit and vegetables until Lidl began offering them at discount rates.

“I couldn't shop for fresh fruit and veg because it was too expensive.”

Of course, O'Neill is still a relatively young man, and can make the journey to a discounter, an option that might not be available to an elderly person.

It is important to note that the Consumer Strategy Group, chaired by Ann Fitzgerald, had plenty of other suggestions that could combat food poverty, such as increasing the number of fruit and vegetable licences granted to casual traders.

Fitzgerald found that Ireland was the most expensive country in the eurozone for fruit, vegetables and potatoes.

She noted that the Irish fruit and vegetable market was moderately concentrated, with three quarters of produce sold in the multiples.

Unlike other European countries, fruit and vegetable markets are not a significant channel for fresh produce sales. The operation of such markets is governed by the Casual Trading Act 1995, which provides that casual traders need licences.

Three years ago, the Competition Authority investigated how the act had been implemented by local authorities.

“It found a lack of consistency in the implementation of the act, notably large variations in fees, differences in the level of facilities being provided and the provision of pitches that were too small for traders' stalls,” the Consumer Strategy Group noted.

Besides recommending the abolition of the Groceries Order, Fitzgerald also advised Enterprise and Employment Minister Micheál Martin to increase the number of licences granted to traders and apply a consistent approach to casual trading regulations across all local authorities by means of statutory guidelines.

This could pave the way for more casual trading such as vans selling fruit and veg to housing estates without adequate shopping facilities.

The Consumer Strategy Group also had a message for Environment Minister Dick Roche.

It recommended that local authorities should be required to demonstrate how the needs of consumers have been taken into account in planning matters.

It also suggested the retail planning guidelines should be interpreted in a way that promotes competition.

RGDATA has protested that it is not against competition, and that it only objects to new projects that breach the retail planning guidelines. But the question is to what extent the guidelines, as currently worded, take account of consumer needs.

Martin indicated last week that the Groceries Order was flawed and outdated, suggesting that he is paving the way for changes to the order.

The proposal for changes comes at a time of mounting consumer anger about the cost of living in Ireland.

The Annual Competitiveness Report published by state agency Forfás last week found that, while the economy performed well last year, Ireland was falling behind its peers in continental Europe and North America in terms of prices and costs.

While Irish prices and costs are no longer increasing at a rate faster than elsewhere in the EU, it said, they have stabilised at a much higher level.

Of course, Forfás wasn't just talking about grocery prices. But tackling grocery prices would be a good start.

 

 

RGDATA is once again trying to block your freedom to choose where you do your shopping.

Please sign this petition to tell RGDATA that the People of Drogheda area WANT the right to choose where they shop.

Would you like to help with our petition
Please feel free to contact us about this issues.
If you'd like to help with our petition.
or Phone 086 2726429
 
You are visitor Since April 2000