|
International Science News
Science
Is Disadvantaged In U.S. Single-Parent Homes
Children in single-parent homes in the U.S. are at a greater
disadvantage in math and science than children in single-parent
homes in other industrialized countries, according to Penn State
researchers.
Most of the research linking single-parenthood to childrens
school performance has been done with single nations, says
Dr. Suet-ling Pong, associate professor of education and sociology
and demography. We do not know much about the impact of
single parenthood across cultures and countries.
The assumption in the United States is that single parents have
lower economic resources than two-parent homes and that single
parents also have less available time to spend on getting involved
with their childrens educations.
Pong, working with Gillian Hampden-Thompson, graduate student
in educational policy studies at Penn State and Dr. Jaap Dronkers,
professor of sociology, European University Institute, Firenze
Ferrovia, Italy, suggested that children of single-parent households
living in countries with stronger family policies would fare better
than those in countries with weak family policies because the
financial and support benefits of strong family policies would
compensate both for money and time.
The researchers looked at 9-year-old third and fourth graders
who participated in the Third International Math and Science Study
from 25 countries. From the total group, they then chose 10 industrialized
countries with similar cultural traditions to the U.S. for comparison.
These countries were Canada, Norway, Iceland, Australia, New Zealand,
the Netherlands, Austria, Scotland, England and Ireland.
"For both academic subjects - math and science -
the largest performance gap between children from single-parent
homes and those from two-parent families is found in the U.S.,
Pong and Hampden-Thompson told attendees at the American Sociological
Association meeting Tuesday (Aug 21) in Anaheim. In other
words, the U.S. ranks bottom among the 11 developed countries
in terms of the equality of school performance between children
from these two types of families.
Data from all 25 countries suggest that two-parent households
predominate, but the percentages of two-parent homes are highest
in Southeast Asia and lowest in North America and the Pacific
Rim countries of Australia and New Zealand.
Over half the countries have negative associations with single-parent
families and math and science achievement, but the U.S. and New
Zealand show by far the greatest effect.
Even after adjusting for family resources and other variables,
the U.S. single-parent students are still worse off than Australian,
Icelandic and Dutch students in math and than Austrian, Australian,
Icelandic, Irish, Dutch and Norwegian students in science.
The researchers found that in the 10 countries compared with
the U.S., children of single parents in countries with strong
family policies are less negatively affected in their math and
science studies than children in countries with weak policies.
Strong family policies include financial benefits, child or family
allowances, childcare costs and paid maternity leave.
The U.S. is clearly behind the other industrialized countries
in providing financial and child care assistance to poor and single-parent
households, says Pong. At the same time, the U.S.
also ranks last on academic resilience of children from single-parent
homes.
Public discussions of the U.S. welfare system, especially by
politicians, often suggest that family or welfare policies may
reinforce undesirable behaviors and create non-traditional families.
The researchers believe that their data do not lend support to
this argument. Iceland, the Netherlands and Australia, for example,
have more generous welfare systems than the U.S., and these countries
have lower poverty rates. They also have lower teenage fertility
rates and a lower percentage of single-parent families than do
other countries.
The U.S., by contrast, has the least generous welfare system,
and hardly any family policies, yet its teenage fertility rates
are high, and single-parent families are more prevalent than in
any of the countries we studied, says the Penn State researcher.
The U.S. also ranks first in terms of poverty rates.
- By A'ndrea Elyse Messer
[Contact: Dr. Suet-ling Pong, Gillian Hampden-Thompson, A'ndrea
Elyse Messer]
22-Aug-2001
Copyright © 1995-2001 UniSci. All rights reserved.
|