Get
your bills and statements in order
By
Simon Carswell
Sunday Business Post Dublin, Ireland, 17 February, 2002
Warring spouses seeking a judicial separation or divorce should
know every aspect of the family finances -- from the value of
their house down to the size of their electricity bill -- to
prepare for initial consultations with a family lawyer.
Spouses
might think that the reason for the breakdown of their marriage
is the most important detail a family lawyer needs to know.
But when it comes to obtaining a divorce, the lawyers will be
most concerned with the family's financial details.
"In
Ireland there are no grounds for divorce except that you have
lived apart for four years," said Dublin family solicitor
David Bergin.
"This
means that the notion of who's at fault is increasingly irrelevant.
"Fault
is only one factor that a court must take into account when
deciding who gets what -- and a minor one at that.
"Judges
will say that they are not prepared to take into account the
behaviour of either party in the context of a marriage breakdown.
They are making orders purely on financial grounds, bearing
in mind the best interests of the children as a priority."
Muriel
Walls, a family lawyer with Dublin firm McCann Fitzgerald, said:
"The bottom line on the separation is how you parent the
children, hopefully, in a civilised fashion.
"Secondly,
it is an exercise in dismantling, dividing and sharing what
the couple have accumulated through the marriage."
Many
applications for judicial separation and divorce involve detailed
trawls through the family's assets to discover the value of
the family home, holiday homes, pensions, cars and company shares,
down to the value of a spouse's motor and petrol allowances.
"If
people are totally unaware of their financial position, they
should familiarise themselves with it," said Mary Hayes,
a solicitor with Dublin firm Gore & Grimes.
Family
lawyer Eugene Davy said: "The personal background is not
relevant unless there is serious misconduct, such as incidents
of violence or abusive behaviour.
"Clients
should have dates of marriage, birth dates, details of properties,
the general estimate of the values of properties, details of
mortgages -- entire financial details."
Some
judicial separation cases are prolonged due to complex discovery
orders to find out how much each spouse is actually worth.
This
can involve an invasive search for separating spouses who run
their own businesses. Each spouse is entitled to seek chapter
and verse on the other's finances.
Embarrassing
details can surface during this process.
"Divorce
is not just a family issue," says Walls.
"It
affects every aspect of the family's finances so, if the husband
is a businessman with several companies and properties, they
will come under the microscope in the family proceedings. Sometimes,
it's difficult to convince husbands that they are actually going
to have to produce the company accounts for the past three years.
"They
find that very intrusive. But if you try to avoid it, you will
be tarred with the accusation that there is something to hide.
That reaps its own whirlwind of mistrust."
One
barrister told of a case about three years ago involving a disgruntled
wife, a missing briefcase and an offshore account.
The
wife, who was in the midst of separation proceedings, had alleged
that her husband had an offshore account, but none could be
found by her legal team. One day she received a visitor at the
family home where she was living.
It
was an airline employee returning her husband's briefcase, which
had been lost or stolen on a business trip.
In
the briefcase she discovered details of a Cayman Islands bank
account in both her and her husband's names, which contained
a considerable sum of money.
She
travelled to the bank, emptied the account and informed her
husband on her return what she had done. The separation proceedings
were settled a short time later.
Many
applications for divorce and judicial separation settle on the
steps of the court, but some go to full hearing, which can last
a day or more.
During
the hearing, both spouses have an opportunity to explain their
side of the story before a judge.
As
many as six cases can be heard in a day in the Riverbank Courthouse
in Dublin. Normally, two judges hear separation and divorce
cases in the Dublin Circuit Family Court, but a third has been
assigned recently to deal with the backlog.
The
main role of the court is to divide up the family's assets and
make sure dependent children are looked after, but many spouses
use court hearing to get things off their chest.
"Court
can be a catharsis," says Hayes. "I have known cases
where I have broken my back to get separation agreements --
and come a divorce, the two of them are at each other's throats.
"People
want to go into court and tell their story and let the judge
make a decision. It's about closure -- somebody has finally
heard their story."